BUG: Error 4601 When DBO Assigns Permissions for a View

ID: Q170446

The information in this article applies to:
BUG #: 16830

SYMPTOMS

You may experience the following error message when a database owner (DBO) assigns permissions for a view that contains 2^N - 1 columns, where N is >= 3 (such as 7, 15, 31, 63... in decimal or 111, 1111, 11111, 111111... in binary):

Msg 4601, Level 16, State 1
Only owner <%.*s> of object <%.*s>,in database %.*s
can GRANT/REVOKE this permission.

The following scripts demonstrate this problem:

Step 1: Connect to SQL Server as a systems administrator (SA) from ISQL/w. 

   USE pubs
   GO
   sp_dropalias pubsdbo
   GO
   sp_droplogin pubsdbo
   GO
   sp_addlogin pubsdbo, NULL, pubs
   GO
   sp_addalias pubsdbo, dbo
   GO
   SETUSER
   GO
   IF EXISTS
      (SELECT NULL FROM sysobjects
       WHERE id = object_id('user1.user1view') and type = 'V')
      DROP VIEW user1.user1view
   GO
   sp_dropuser user1
   GO
   sp_dropuser user2
   GO
   sp_droplogin user1
   GO
   sp_droplogin user2
   GO
   sp_addlogin user1, NULL, pubs
   GO
   sp_addlogin user2, NULL, pubs
   GO
   sp_adduser user1
   GO
   sp_adduser user2
   GO
   GRANT CREATE VIEW TO user1
   GO
   SETUSER 'user1'
   GO
   IF EXISTS
      (SELECT NULL FROM sysobjects
      WHERE id = object_id('user1.user1view') and type = 'V')
      DROP VIEW user1.user1view
   GO
   CREATE VIEW user1view
   AS SELECT
         1 as c1,
         2 as c2,
         3 as c3,
         4 as c4,
         5 as c5,
         6 as c6,
         7 as c7
   GO
   GRANT ALL ON user1view TO DBO WITH GRANT OPTION
   GO
   SETUSER
   GO

Step 2: Connect to SQL Server and log on as "pubsdbo" with no password. 

   GRANT SELECT ON user1.user1view TO user2
   GO


WORKAROUND

To work around this problem, create a view with the number of columns that has fewer or more than 2^N - 1 columns, where N >= 3.


STATUS

Microsoft has confirmed this to be a problem in Microsoft SQL Server version 6.5. We are researching this problem and will post new information here in the Microsoft Knowledge Base as it becomes available. 


Keywords          : kbprg kbusage SSrvGen SSrvProg kbbug6.50 
Version           : 6.5
Platform          : WINDOWS 
Issue type        : kbbug

Last Reviewed: April 21, 1999